DNP Health Policy Case Study: DNP Versus PhD Preparation in Nursing
DNP Health Policy Case Study
According to the American Association of Colleges of Nursing (AACN) (2026), advanced nursing practice entails nurses pursuing more qualifications to meet career development needs and improve patient care delivery and outcomes, including generating new knowledge through research and translating research evidence into clinical practice. Two critical terminal nursing degrees: Doctor of Nursing Practice (DNP) and Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) provide pathways for nurses to attain terminal and advanced-level qualifications. AACN (2026) asserts that these degrees are complementary and not competing doctoral pathways due to their purpose, educational focus, research preparation, clinical practice, leadership, and expected contribution to the nursing profession.
Differences Between DNP and PhD Preparation in Nursing
The DNP degree focuses on clinical practice and leadership in a clinical environment. However, the core purpose of a PhD is to enhance research and academic scholarship. Therefore, the primary purpose of a DNP degree is to be an advanced practice nurse, lead nursing practice teams, and improve systems to enhance patient care. On its part, a PhD prepares advanced practice nurses to conduct more research and contribute to nursing scholarship through the development of new knowledge and theories. The educational focus of a DNP includes taking between 2 and 4 years, with certification options in various practice specialties and core competencies in leadership, systems improvement, collaboration, population health, and healthcare policy development and implementation (Garcia et al., 2025). On its part, a PhD in nursing requires nurses to undertake a 4-to-6-year program with certification in education, public health policy, and healthcare innovation research, among other areas. PhD nurses attain core competencies in research development, critique theories and nursing literature, designing research, and applying analytical approaches, among other areas of research interest.
DNP nurses assume leadership roles in clinical practice. A DNP degree’s core contribution to the nursing profession entails increasing clinical expertise and translating evidence into practice as well as leading quality improvement initiative as well as influencing policy development, and implementing organizational changes (Kirkland et al., 2026). On its part, a PhD contributes to the nursing profession by improving nursing research, generating new knowledge, and increasing scientific inquiry to improve care delivery, especially by generating evidence-based practice (EBP) interventions for translation in nursing practice.
Implications of different Treatment of DNP and PhD
Treating these terminal degrees as equivalent or different has significant policy and professional implications, especially concerning faculty appointments, tenure, research expectations, clinical leadership, and advancement within academic settings or institutions. Considering these degrees as equivalent ensures that faculty have a wide pool for appointment, enabling them to address shortages in faculty requirements (Bekman & Solnica, 2026). However, DNP-prepared nurse faculty may have an unsustainable burden in faculty due to limited research background and educational pedagogy (Garcia et al., 2025). Conversely, recognizing them as different leads to a dual-track system with clear career pathways, with each degree’s core competencies leading to better outcomes, and ensures a two-tier approach that ensures each qualification focuses on a clear pathway.
Concerning tenure eligibility, if considered equivalent, institutions have to redefine the criteria, implying various aspects such as scholarship of application and evidence-based practice implementation as well as clinical innovation. However, treating them differently means that PhD will retain faculty positions while DNP faculty remain on clinical contracts within healthcare settings (Kirkland et al., 2026). The research and scholarship expectations concerning the generation of knowledge and its translation in clinical practice mean that the two qualifications are complementary, as one develops research and the DNP implements the evidence in practice (Rosenfeld et al., 2022). The leadership considerations require both to be treated as equivalent since they all prepare nurses to assume leadership roles, either in research settings or clinical practice environments.
Strategies to Promote Appropriate and Equitable Recognition
Nursing leaders can create clear models that value the unique contributions of each pathway, especially underpinning the distinct nature of each doctorate. Nursing leaders can implement diverse strategies that align qualifications, professional roles, and institutional recognition based on their core purposes and contributions Kirkland et al., 2026. These include harmonization of institutional culture and recognition, clarification of academic roles and curricular boundaries, and clear advocacy of each degree to prevent ambiguous requirements during recruitment (Rosenfeld et al., 2022). As such, nursing leaders and institutions, as well as programs, must develop approaches and frameworks that distinguish these terminal degrees to reduce and prevent confusion and ambiguity, especially for faculty requirements as well as clinical practice leadership and roles.
References
American Association of Colleges of Nursing (AACN) (2026). The Doctor of Nursing Practice:
Current Issues and Clarifying Recommendations. https://www.aacnnursing.org/Portals/0/PDFs/White-Papers/DNP-White-Paper.pdf
Bekman, N., & Solnica, A. (2026). Redefining the journey: A scoping systematic review of PhD
and DNP career trajectories. Worldviews on Evidence‐Based Nursing, 23(1), e70110. https://doi.org/10.1111/wvn.70110
Garcia, T. J., Bai, J., Shen, N., Smith, L., & Koszalinski, R. S. (2025). PhD‐DNP Collaboration:
An Integrative Review of Scholarly Partnerships in Nursing. Research in Nursing &
health, 48(1), 41-62. DOI: 10.1002/nur.22423
Kirkland, T., Zappas, M., Pitts, C. J., Thaxton, C., Posey, K., & DeClerk, L. (2026). DNP-PhD:
A transformative shift. The Nurse Practitioner, 51(4), 12.
DOI: 10.1097/01.NPR.0000000000000424
Rosenfeld, P., Glassman, K., Vetter, M., & Smith, B. (2022). A comparative study of PhD and
DNP nurses in an integrated health care system. Nursing Outlook, 70(1), 145-153.
DOI: 10.1016/j.outlook.2021.07.010.
CLICK HERE TO ORDER A PLAGIARISM-FREE PAPER
DNP Health Policy Case Study: DNP Versus PhD Preparation in Nursing
Scenario:
A university is reviewing its doctoral nursing programs because faculty, healthcare organizations, and nursing leaders continue to debate the appropriate roles of the Doctor of Nursing Practice (DNP) and Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) in nursing. The American Association of Colleges of Nursing (AACN) identifies the DNP as a practice-focused doctorate designed to prepare nurses for the highest level of nursing practice, leadership, evidence-based practice, quality improvement, policy, and translation of research into practice. In contrast, the PhD is a research-focused doctorate designed to prepare nurse scientists who generate new knowledge through rigorous research. AACN considers the two degrees complementary rather than competing doctoral pathways.
The university is considering whether DNP-prepared nurses should be considered equally qualified for tenure-track faculty positions, research leadership positions, and other academic roles traditionally associated with PhD-prepared faculty. Some faculty members argue that DNP graduates bring important clinical expertise and are well prepared to translate evidence into practice, lead quality improvement initiatives, influence healthcare policy, and implement organizational change. Other faculty members argue that PhD-prepared nurses have more extensive preparation in research methodology, theory development, scientific inquiry, and generation of new knowledge and therefore should remain the preferred credential for research-intensive faculty positions. AACN recognizes that DNP and PhD programs have different purposes, competencies, and outcomes, with the DNP emphasizing application and translation of evidence and the PhD emphasizing development of new scientific knowledge.
The university’s DNP program director has been asked to provide a recommendation to the Dean regarding whether the institution’s policies should distinguish between DNP- and PhD-prepared nurses when determining faculty qualifications, academic advancement, research expectations, and leadership opportunities. The DNP program director must consider whether treating the degrees as interchangeable would misrepresent their different educational purposes or whether restricting opportunities based solely on degree title could undervalue the expertise of DNP-prepared nurses.
Student Task: Write a 5-paragraph APA-format essay addressing the following:
- Analyze the differences between DNP and PhD preparation in nursing, including the purpose, educational focus, research preparation, clinical practice, leadership, and expected contributions to the nursing profession.
- Discuss the policy and professional implications of treating DNP and PhD degrees as equivalent or different, particularly regarding faculty appointments, tenure, research expectations, clinical leadership, and advancement within academic institutions.
- Propose strategies nursing leaders can use to promote appropriate and equitable recognition of both doctoral pathways, while ensuring that faculty qualifications and professional roles are aligned with the competencies and purposes of each degree.
Students should support their analysis with at least 2–3 current scholarly or authoritative sources, including at least one source from AACN or another recognized nursing organization.